Sure, It Won an Oscar. But Is It Criterion?

Dan

March 8

I enjoyed Joshua Hunt's recent New York Times article on the Criterion Collection:

Always in awe of auteurs but never in their thrall, Criterion producers have never been afraid to look beyond the biggest and most marketable names. When Criterion released "Peeping Tom," a '60s psychosexual thriller by the English director Michael Powell, the company chose not to ask Scorsese to record the audio commentary, though he would have been the obvious candidate, having done them for other Criterion editions of Powell films. The job instead went to a feminist scholar, Laura Mulvey, the author of the influential essay "Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema," which brought forward the concept of "the male gaze." Over the years, such decisions added up to an editorial voice that became influential, even authoritative, transforming a mere distributor of films into a creator of film culture.

There are also some nice details about the look of the collection:

Criterion's distinctive visual language began to emerge in the early '90s when [Rebekah] Audic, the former head of design, started building up its art staff with an aim "to really show the power of these films through the cover designs," she told me. To do that it was sometimes necessary to go through every frame of film in search of the perfect image. Other times, images alone were not enough. "For the cover of 'RoboCop,' we had an actual aluminum-cast letterpress plate made and then photographed the plate with a 4-by-5 camera," Audic says. It took days, she told me, but "using a physical piece of metal gave it a feeling of aesthetic truth."

I don't know if the Criterion Designs book, written and edited by Criterion art director Eric Skillman, is still available. It must be 10 years old now (dies) -- I didn't see it on the Criterion website -- but there's a nice piece about it on AIGA's Eye on Design blog from around the time it came out. There is also a Criterion Designs blog, but it hasn't been updated for a little while (am I imagining that Eric Skillman had a blog himself once upon a time?).

Oh and as an aside, the illustration for the NYT article is by Ben Denzer, who also designs book covers, and is the creator of Ice Cream Books should you ever need to pair great literature with frozen desserts (and who doesn't?).